As I sit tonight watching the CBS news report, I watch with a broken heart as a family desparately searches for a lost 13 year old in Missouri. He got off the bus with a friend, was walking home as usual, the friend went into a neighbor's home for a moment and when he came out the little boy was gone and a strange white truck was speeding out of the neighborhood. As afternoon turned to night, the police and family still frantically search. Every parent/family member/guardians nightmare. Yes, it is rare that these things happen but what if it was our one in a thousanth turn? What if that were my child? I can't even begin to imagine the pain, fear and heartsickness - not knowing.
NEVER TALK TO STRANGERS - one of my children's favorite books when they were small, is something children are taught from the time they are young, but they watch their parent's repeatedly violate that rule themselves. I'm a sales person. I talk to strangers for a living. (To overcome this our family rule was "you can talk to strangers that are your size" - this helped social skills without causing too much fear and paranoia)
And children themselves are encouraged to violate it. "Say hello to the nice lady." "Answer the man's question." What children actually learn is: never talk to strangers unless they are wearing a clown suit or uniform, work at the bank, are handing out tasty samples, or are especially nice.
Young children who are told not to talk to strangers can usually be coerced to do so anyway. In a revealing research project children were successfully lured away from their inattentive parents time and time again--despite these parents emphatically insisting a short time earlier that their children would never leave the park with a stranger. On average, it took thirty-five seconds to lure each child from the safety of the park.
The rule "Never talk to strangers" actually reduces child's safety in other ways. "Never trust a stranger" implies that people who you know, will not harm you. The opposite is far more often true.
The issue isn't strangers, it's strangeness. It's inappropriate behavior: a stare held too long, a smile that curls too slowly, a narrowing or widening of the eyes, a rapid looking away. --Gavin De Becker, Protecting the Gift
As children grow up, our longing for certainty grows stronger wanting to be sure that the park is safe, the beach is safe, the boy will drive carefully. We'll never be sure. Yet we can be certain we've educated ourselves, made the best choice possible with the time and resources available, and not denied or discounted our intuition. This means being willing to hesitate even when it's inconvenient, unpopular, or downright rude, such as canceling a sleepover at the very last minute because of a feeling something's wrong.
He was so nice" is a comment often heard from people who were later victimized. Teach children niceness doesn't equal goodness. No matter how engaging a stranger might be, never lose site of the context: He is what he is, a stranger who approached you. The human being is the only prey in nature that cooperates in its own victimization.
While many parents are afraid of considering the details of how someone might hurt their children, ignorance, denial, or worry is not an effective strategy. Worry enhances risk because as you worry about imagined dangers, you are distracted from what's actually happening. Perception, not worry, serves safety.
Bottom line: The issue isn't strangers, it's strangeness. It's inappropriate behavior: a stare held too long, a smile that curls too slowly, a narrowing or widening of the eyes, a rapid looking away.--Gavin De Becker, Protecting the Gift
SAFETY TIPS FOR PARENTS:
If Lost, Go to a Police Officer. Is a mythical rule that rarely enhances safety. Young children can't tell the difference between a police officer and security guard (the latter are from the employment pool that gives more serial killers and rapists jobs than there is time to talk about!). Even if a child can identify a police officer, it could take hours to find one, and it might not happen at all. "Go to the manager" poses the same problem as identifying a police officer. That small name tag is several feet above a child's eye level.
Instead: Teach children that if they are lost, go to a woman. Why? If a child selects a woman, it is highly unlikely she will be a predator. A man approached by a lost child seeking help may say, "Head over there to the manager's desk," a woman will get involved and stay involved until the child is safe.
As to "Don't wander off in public," saying this to kids makes sense--so long as we don't rely upon their compliance.
Instead try: "If you can't see me, then I can't see you" as a safe rule of thumb, giving them freedom to move on their own but not out of sight. Along with this advice, dress children in brightly colored, distinctive, easily describable clothing, and when in unfamiliar areas, have an agreement such as "If anyone gets lost, we'll meet at the ... (have a designated meeting spot that all in the family know about."
DO YOUR CHILDREN KNOW:
Your full name, phone number and address
How to honor their feelings--if someone makes them feel uncomfortable - it's okay to say NO
You (the parents) are strong enough to hear about any experience they've had;
It's OK to be assertive;
How to ask for help;
How to choose who to ask;
It's OK to strike, even to injure, someone if the children believe that they are in danger, and that you'll support any action they take as a result of feeling afraid;
It's OK to make noise, to scream, yell, run;
If someone tries to force them to go somewhere, what they scream should include, "This is not my father";
If someone says "Don't yell," then yell
If someone says "Don't tell," tell
To fully resist going out of public view with someone they don't know, and to resist going anywhere with someone who tries to persuade them
To Trust Their Intuition
You may also want to provide them with some sort of personal protection device such as a small mace for pre-or teenage girls or personal alarms. Again, this isn't about causing parania and fear in our children so they can't function as adults in a society where "Talking to strangers" may be their career. But rather a way of teaching them rules of self preservation that will keep them safe as they grow.
Children's Books:
My Body Is Private by Linda Walvoord Girard
Who Is a Stranger and What Should I Do? by Linda Walvoord Girard
What Would You Do? A Kid's Guide to Tricky and Sticky Situations by Linda Schwartz